Trudeau and Trump are worlds apart on the Canada-U.S. border closure

Trudeau and Trump are worlds apart on the Canada-U.S. border closure

Though Canada and the U.S. have agreed to shut their shared land border to non-essential journey, they do not seem to agree on a number of associated points — together with what to do subsequent. 

Greater than seven months after the border closed because of the COVID-19 pandemic, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and U.S. President Donald Trump have provided up contradictory messages about what occurs now. 

The Canada-U.S. border is about to reopen on Oct. 21, however Trudeau implied this week that the closure shall be prolonged. 

In an interview Wednesday on Winnipeg podcast The Begin, Trudeau stated Canada plans to maintain the border closed so long as COVID-19 case counts within the U.S. stays excessive. 

“We hold extending the border closures as a result of the US just isn’t in a spot the place we’d really feel snug reopening these borders,” he stated. 

4 weeks prior, Trump offered a different prognosis for the Canada-U.S. border closure.

“We’re wanting on the border with Canada — Canada would really like it open,” he stated on the White Home on Sept. 18.

“So we’re gonna be opening the borders fairly quickly…. We wish to get again to regular enterprise.”

WATCH | Trump says on Sept. 18 U.S.-Canada border may reopen ‘fairly quickly’:

U.S. President Donald Trump responded to a query concerning the border as he left the White Home on Friday, Sept. 18. zero:48

International affairs knowledgeable Edward Alden stated the disconnect between the 2 leaders suggests there are at the moment no joint discussions about an eventual reopening plan. 

“With the Trudeau authorities saying, ‘No, do not open’ … and President Trump saying, ‘Oh, I feel we’ll reopen someday quickly,’ that is no grounds for a critical government-to-government negotiation,” stated Alden, a professor of U.S.-Canada financial relations at Western Washington College in Bellingham, Wash.

Although many Canadians support the border closure, which took impact in late March, it has devastated the tourism business, separated family members and damage border communities in each Canada and the U.S. 

International coverage knowledgeable Edward Alden believes Canada and the U.S. is probably not participating in any dialogue on a doable reopening of the border. (submitted by Edward Alden)

Alden stated he understands why the border is closed for now, however that it is vital to start out laying the groundwork for a reopening plan.

“The issue of not having these negotiations is, when can we presumably have a way of when will probably be secure to reopen the border?”

CBC Information requested each the Canadian and U.S. governments concerning the destiny of the border closure and acquired disparate solutions. 

The U.S. Division of Homeland Safety stated the 2 international locations are exploring the loosening of some restrictions.  

“We imagine each the U.S. and Canada are working properly collectively to overview potential areas for future off-ramping, when public well being circumstances allow,” a DHS spokesperson stated in an electronic mail. 

However a spokesperson for Invoice Blair — Canada’s public security minister — provided a much less definitive assertion on the subsequent steps. 

“We are going to proceed to guage the most effective public well being info obtainable to us to decide on when and the right way to reopen our border,” the spokesperson stated in an electronic mail. 

“This choice shall be made in Canada.”

According to Reuters — which spoke with well-placed Washington and Ottawa sources final month — the U.S. had floated the concept of stress-free some border restrictions, however Canadian officers confirmed little enthusiasm.

Canadians suggested to not go to U.S.

In one other disconnect between the 2 international locations, Trudeau is warning Canadians to not fly to the U.S., whereas the U.S. is welcoming Canadian air passengers.

Though the U.S. agreed to shut its shared land border with Canada, it nonetheless allows Canadians to fly to the country for leisure journey. The U.S. authorities declined to explain why it made this choice. 

Conversely, Canada will not enable Individuals to enter for non-essential journey by any mode of transport except they get a special exemption

Some Canadian snowbirds plan to move to the southern U.S. this winter, regardless of the advice to keep away from all non-essential journey. (Marsha Halper/The Miami Herald/The Related Press)

CBC Information just lately reported on some Canadian snowbirds planning to fly to Florida this winter — as a result of they’ll. 

When requested about Canadians — together with snowbirds — flying to the U.S., Trudeau stated within the podcast interview that they need to keep residence because of the COVID-19 pandemic. 

“Individuals have to acknowledge that they are placing themselves in danger, they’re placing their family members in danger.” he stated. “The advice is to keep away from non-essential journey, and that is for folks’s personal security.”

Case numbers down in solar states

Trudeau and Trump additionally disagree on the COVID-19 standing of among the U.S. solar locations Canadians may be tempted to go to this winter.  

“I do know there’s lots of people very frightened about what’s occurring south of the border in Florida and Arizona and California and different locations the place the virus just isn’t underneath management — far much less underneath management than we’re right here,” Trudeau stated within the interview.

Nevertheless, when Trump urged the border would quickly reopen, he stated that Florida and Arizona are “doing very properly.”

In keeping with U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention data, new every day COVID-19 case numbers in Arizona, Florida and California have declined dramatically since their worrisome peaks in the summertime.

In the meantime, COVID-19 case numbers have surged just lately in some Canadian provinces

Trump made a degree of highlighting this reality in a speech final week.

“All around the world you see huge flare-ups,” he advised a crowd of supporters. “Huge flare-ups in Canada.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *